Nestled within the historic Church of the Heavenly Rest along Museum Mile, directly opposite Central Park, the Church's Upper East Side Café is one of our most special locations — operated by Bluestone Lane and beloved by the local community. In partnership with the Church, we proudly operate the café on behalf of the church as part of this extraordinary community space — welcoming locals, visitors, and parishioners alike throughout the day. On weekends, we also serve coffee alongside Church services, extending the ritual of gathering from café to congregation. Framed by the Church's original sandstone architecture and vaulted archways, the space offers a calm, light-filled setting that feels both elevated and deeply grounded in its surroundings. It's a place to pause — whether for a morning coffee, a long brunch, or a quiet moment between walks along Fifth Avenue. Our menu reflects Bluestone Lane's signature approach to modern café culture — seasonal, produce-driven dishes designed to complement our specialty coffee program. From Avocado Smash and house-made granola to our much-loved Gluten-Free Banana Bread, the offering is familiar, nourishing, and consistently high quality. Beyond daytime service, we also collaborate with the Church to host evening and special events — bringing people together through shared experiences, conversation, and community. With indoor table service and outdoor seating along Fifth Avenue, this is a destination to discover — where café culture meets one of New York's most iconic and historic settings. To host your next event with us, visit our Private Events page.
Keywords Australian Restaurant, Café, Coffee Shop, Espresso Bar, Avocado Toast, Flat white, Coffee near me, Best coffee, Best brunch, Cafe near me, Cafe brunch, Healthy brunch, Avocado toast, Avocado smash, Brooklyn Coffee, Coffee Shops, coffee and tea, healthy restaurants, coffee house, australian, bluestone restaurant, brunch restaurant, coffee & tea shops, coffee shops near me, cafe restaurants, coffee bar, internet cafes, breakfast cafe, coffee & tea restaurants.
American Express, Visa, Discover, MasterCard
Our classic avo smash with sheep's milk feta, heirloom tomatoes & soft herbs on toasted multigrain. Make it vegan by removing feta. Allergens: D = Contains dairy, S = Contains soy, G = Contains gluten, SE = Contains sesame seeds
Categories: 312
Chili shallot-folded eggs with sheep's milk feta, avocado & sesame seeds topped with chili oil. Allergens: D = Contains dairy, E = Contains egg, S = contains soy, SE = Contains sesame seeds, G = Contains gluten
Categories: 528
Scrambled eggs, bacon, avocado, sheep's milk feta, crispy potato & guajillo sauce served with a side salad or wedges. Allergens: D = Contains dairy, E = Contains egg, S = Contains soy, G = Contains gluten
Categories: 704
Crispy bacon, avocado, arugula, tomato, a fried egg & garlic aioli on a brioche roll served with a side salad or wedges Allergens: E = Contains egg, S = Contains soy, G = Contains gluten
Categories: 584
Egg whites, sautéed spinach, roasted tomatoes, avocado, lentils, sheep's milk feta & chimichurri mayo served with a dressed salad. Allergens: D = Contains dairy, E = Contains egg whites, S = contains soy, G = Contains gluten
Categories: 584
Delicious scrambled eggs, dill mayo, bacon, avocado, cheddar, and fresh spinach. Allergens: G = Contains gluten, D = Contains dairy, E = Contains egg, S = Contains soy
Categories: 440
Sautéed baby kale, cherry tomatoes, sheep's milk feta, avocado & warm quinoa grain topped with a poached egg. Make it vegan by removing feta & poached egg. D = Contains dairy, E = Contains egg
Categories: 424
Avocado smash on toasted multigrain with two poached eggs, smoked bacon, roasted tomatoes, field mushrooms & baby kale. Allergens: E = Contains egg, S = contains soy, SE = Contains sesame seeds, G = Contains gluten
Categories: 512
Half portions of both our classic Avocado Smash and GF Collective Granola. The perfect brekkie pair. Allergens: D = Contains dairy, N = Contains tree nuts, S = Contains soy, SE = Contains sesame seeds, G = Contains gluten, E = Contains egg
Categories: 424
Our GF granola served with Greek yogurt, lemon curd & fresh berries. Allergens: GF = Gluten free, D = Contains dairy, N = Contains tree nuts, SE = Contains sesame
Categories: 696
GF banana bread served with whipped cow's milk ricotta, fresh berries & roasted pecans drizzled in locallly sourced honey. GF = Gluten-free, N = Contains tree nuts, D = Contains dairy
Categories: 450
Pancakes with blueberry compote, fresh blueberries, freeze dried raspberries & maple syrup G= Contains gluten, D= Contains dairy, E= Contains egg, S= Contains soy
Categories: 570
Lemon ricotta pancakes with whipped ricotta, fresh berries, citrus curd, edible petals, freeze dried raspberries & maple syrup. G= Contains gluten D = Contains dairy, E = Contains egg, S = Contains soy
Categories: 560
Waffles with blueberry compote, fresh blueberries, freeze dried raspberries & maple syrup G= Contains gluten, D= Contains dairy, E= Contains egg, S= Contains soy
Categories: 410
Lemon ricotta waffles with whipped ricotta, fresh berries, citrus curd, edible petals, freeze dried raspberries & maple syrup. G= Contains gluten D = Contains dairy, E = Contains egg, S = Contains soy
Categories: 390
Fresh baked butter croissant with scrambled egg, bacon, cheddar & chipotle mayo. Allergens: G = Contains gluten, D = Contains dairy, E = Contains egg
Categories: 408
Thick cut multigrain served with choice of Vegemite & butter, jam & butter or almond butter. Allergens: G = Contains gluten, S = Contains soy, SE = Contains sesame
Categories: 376
*2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary. Additional nutritional information available upon request.
Chickpeas, marinated peppers, kalamata olives, labneh, cherry tomatoes, halloumi, smoked salmon & a soft-boiled egg; finished with sumac, dried oregano, clover honey & a lemon vinaigrette D = Contains dairy, E = Contains Egg, F = Contains Fis
Categories: 680
Grilled spiced chicken breast, baby kale, sheep's milk feta, avo smash, heirloom tomato and cayenne vinaigrette. Served w/ crisps G= contains gluten D = Contains dairy, S = Contains soy
Categories: 720
Crafted with care and bursting with vibrant flavors, this sandwich is a celebration of fresh, seasonal ingredients. burrata, prosciutto, spicy jam, arugula greens with a lemon zesty vinaigrette on sourdough. Served w/ crisps Allergens: G = Contains gluten, D= Contains dairy
Categories: 780
A culinary journey through the forest, a celebration of flavors that will transport your taste buds to a realm of pure delight. Portabella mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, arugula, truffle aioli, sourdough. Served w/ crisps Allergens: G = Contains gluten, D= Contains dairy
Categories: 650
Sliced turkey, garlic aioli, bacon, avocado smash, tomatoes, arugula & pickled onions on sourdough. G = Contains Gluten, S = Contains Soy, E = Contains Egg
Categories: 920
Breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella & parmesan, w/ red sauce & fresh arugula, on buttered sourdough G = Contains gluten D = Contains dairy S = Contains soy
Categories: 700
Chicken salad, cheddar cheese, spinach, dill & avocado between toasted sourdough bread; served with a side of crisps. Allergens: G = Contains gluten, D= Contains dairy
Categories: 800
Warm mixed grains bowl with lemon and garlic grilled chicken, seasonal roasted vegetables, sheep's milk feta, drizzled EVOO & a tahini dressing. Allergens: D = Contains dairy, G = Contains gluten, SE = Contains sesame
Categories: 728
Whether enjoyed as a light lunch or a satisfying dinner, this salad is sure to tantalize your senses and leave you craving more. Arugula, lemon garlic chicken, dill, basil, cucumber, cherry tomatoes, kalamata olives, feta, orzo & pickled onions w/ a lemon vinaigrette. Allergens: G = Contains gluten, D= Contains dairy, S= Contains Soy
Categories: 470
A vibrant bowl featuring kale, quinoa, grilled corn, lentils, cherry tomatoes, spiced chicken, and feta. Served with a tahini dressing D= Contains Dairy, S = Contains Soy, SE = Contains Sesame
Categories: 520
A refreshing mix of summer greens with crisp cucumber, fennel edamame, toasted seeds, pickled onion and feta tossed in a tangy vinaigrette and topped an avocado half. D = Contains dairy S = Contains soy
Categories: 560
A delicious medley of tomatoes, light cream, spices and garlic all simmered in a rich broth with a side of toast. D = Contains dairy
Categories: 290
Homestyle herbed chicken broth loaded with white meat chicken, carrots, celery and pasta with a side of toast. G = Contains gluten, E = Contains egg
Categories: 120
*2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary. Additional nutritional information available upon request.
Roasted carrots drizzled with olive oil and seasoned with salt and pepper, topped with feta, pumpkin seeds, and fresh micro herbs. Allergens: N = Contains tree nuts, D = Contains dairy
Categories: 450
Crispy potato wedges topped with melted mozzarella and parmesan, finished with crispy bacon. Served with sour cream and chili sauce for dipping. G= contains gluten D = Contains dairy, S = Contains soy
Categories: 500
Side of scrambled eggs.
Categories: 155
A side of our classic avocado smash with lemon juice & salt.
Categories: 150
Side of crispy bacon.
Categories: 150
Thick cut multigrain served with choice of Vegemite & butter, jam & butter or almond butter. Allergens: G = Contains gluten, S = Contains soy, SE = Contains sesame
Categories: 160
A bowl of fresh strawberries, blueberries & raspberries topped with a mint leaf. A sweet addition to every brekkie.
Categories: 45
*2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary. Additional nutritional information available upon request.
The global café favorite. Double espresso with steamed, silky textured milk and one inch of velvety micro-foam.
Categories: 120
An Australian classic. Double espresso with steamed silky textured milk and a thin layer of micro-foam.
Categories: 110
Double espresso with steamed milk and slightly more micro foam than a latte with cocoa dusting on top.
Categories: 110
Single Origin espresso gently resting on a small amount of hot water for dilution, similar to an Americano.
Categories: 0
Our signature flagstaff roast has tasting notes of toasted almonds, vanilla & chocolate with a caramel sweetness and juicy finish.
Categories: 0
A stronger, less diluted spin on a flat white – two shots of espresso in a 4.5oz cup with steamed milk and velvety micro foam, similar to a European Cortado.
Categories: 90
Our new Single-Origin espresso from the Tarqui region of Huila, Colombia. Carefully roasted to highlight unique tasting notes of orange, vanilla, and brown sugar.
Categories: 0
Our signature maverick espresso with a stain of steamed milk and micro foam.
Categories: 50
A single shot of espresso with 3 oz. of steamed, silky textured milk, served in a small glass.
Categories: 75
Chai extract with your choice of milk.
Categories: 145
Double shot of espresso and cocoa spun in a pitcher with steamed, silky textured milk, dusted with chocolate shavings.
Categories: 125
Deliciously rich cocoa spun in a pitcher with steamed, silky textured milk. Served with chocolate shavings.
Categories: 135
An Aussie Favorite. Malted chocolate with your choice of steamed milk.
Categories: 190
BL for the little ones. Steamed and frothed milk with a dusting of cocoa.
*2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary. Additional nutritional information available upon request.
Our signature flagstaff coffee immersed in water for 12 hours to extract and form a rich concentrate.
Categories: 0
Double shot of our signature maverick espresso blend with your choice of milk, poured over ice.
Categories: 120
Rotating Single-Origin espresso poured over ice and water.
Categories: 0
A stronger, less diluted spin on an iced latte – two espresso shots with ice and milk.
Categories: 0
Double shot of espresso and cocoa spun in a pitcher with your choice of milk, poured over ice.
Categories: 270
Chai extract with your choice of milk, poured over ice.
Categories: 120
Malted chocolate with vanilla ice cream and your choice of milk.
Categories: 385
A double shot of espresso with vanilla ice cream and your choice of milk.
Categories: 260
Our signature flagstaff coffee immersed in water for 12 hours to extract and form a rich concentrate, served with vanilla ice cream.
Categories: 170
Vanilla ice-cream served with a double shot of our signature maverick espresso.
*2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary. Additional nutritional information available upon request.
A tropical smoothie inspired by the Aussie coast. This smoothie is a blend of banana, mango puree, pineapple, almond milk, blueberries, vegan cream, protein powder and blue spirulina.
Categories: 300
A vibrant blend of AG1, pineapple, banana, mango, spinach, and orange juice, packed with flavor and nutrients to support energy, immunity, and digestion.
Categories: 267
A healthy dose of antioxidants from fresh mixed strawberries, blueberries & banana plus mint, lemon juice, honey and oat milk.
Categories: 250
A plant-based protein boost with vanilla protein powder, packed with banana, blueberries, almond milk, peanut butter. N = Contains tree nuts
Categories: 290
A powerful blend of bananas, spinach, almond butter, honey, and almond milk, packed full of nutrients to provide a healthy boost for whatever your day entails. N = Contains tree nuts
Categories: 290
Almond milk w/ banana, dates, almond butter, cinnamon & vanilla plant based protein powder N= Contains tree nuts
Categories: 500
*2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary. Additional nutritional information available upon request.
Our cold brewed Melbourne Brekky is a smooth, strong blend of organic Ceylon tea. This robust brew provides a refreshing boost for any time of day.
Green rooibos, raspberry, lemon peel and hibiscus. This non-caffeinated cold brewed tea is tart and refreshing with natural sweetness. Plus, it's full of antioxidants to help toxin release and promote healthy skin.
Ceremonial grade matcha green tea powder that naturally detoxifies the body, is rich in antioxidants, and provides a valuable source of fiber and vitamins made with steamed almond milk.
Categories: 60
Ceremonial grade matcha green tea powder that naturally detoxifies the body, is rich in antioxidants, and provides a valuable source of fiber and vitamins with almond milk.
Categories: 60
Turmeric powder, cinnamon, ginger and black pepper, good for detoxifying the body and reducing inflammation made with steamed almond milk.
Categories: 70
Turmeric powder, cinnamon, ginger and black pepper, good for detoxifying the body and reducing inflammation made with almond milk.
Categories: 70
Dehydrated beet powder that is rich in antioxidants, and good for digestion. This drink is married with a dusting of cocoa and steamed almond milk.
Categories: 60
Dehydrated beet powder that is rich in antioxidants, and good for digestion. This drink is married with a dusting of cocoa and almond milk.
Categories: 60
This smooth, strong blend of organic Ceylon tea can be enjoyed with or without milk and, despite the name, at any time of day.
Twice-refined organic Spanish bergamot oil is blended with organic Ceylon tea and cornflowers to create a clean, refreshing and aromatic blend traditionally appreciated in the afternoon.
A much-loved favorite, this premium blend of organic ginger and lemongrass tea has made its way here from Sri Lanka. The sweet lemongrass balances out the gingery spice, creating a vibrant and energizing brew.
The long, slender leaves of this green tea produce sweet, mellow liquor that contains EGCG, a catechin said to lower the risk of cancer, chronic fatigue and neurological diseases.
A classic herb widely appreciated as a digestive and a revitalizing tonic, organic Egyptian peppermint is picked at the peak cropping season, resulting in a bright, fresh aroma and clean, lasting finish.
Harvested in the warmth of Egypt’s summer, the sweet, aromatic flowers of chamomile calm nerves, soothe stomachs and leave you feeling peaceful and relaxed.
*2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary. Additional nutritional information available upon request.
Freshly cold pressed 8oz juices made with the finest oranges.
Categories: 60
Freshly cold pressed 12oz juices made with the finest cucumber, apple, kale, lemon, ginger root and spinach.
Categories: 70
Freshly cold pressed 12 oz juices made with the finest pineapple, carrot, orange, ginger root, and turmeric.
Categories: 110
Freshly cold pressed 12oz juices made with the finest pineapple, grapefruit, lemon and ginger root.
Categories: 100
*2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary. Additional nutritional information available upon request.
Enjoy our premium hot coffee in a large 96oz coffee box. If you would like milk or additional condiments please ask our team when you pick up.
Enjoy our premium cold brew coffee in a large 96oz coffee box. If you would like milk or additional condiments please ask our team when you pick up.
*2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary. Additional nutritional information available upon request.
Our signature espresso blend in a sleek, guilt-free capsule you can compost at home. Maverick embodies the quintessence of Australian coffee culture—with a full-bodied, well-structured subtlety that leaves you wanting a second cup. All capsules are only compatible for Nespresso® Original machines. Not compatible for Keurigs and Nespresso® VertuoPlusLine.
Big flavor—in a small package you can compost right at home. Riptide is strong enough to pull you in and complex enough to bring you back for seconds—because what’s ebb without flow? Boldly roasted for early risers and dawn riders. All capsules are only compatible for Nespresso® Original machines. Not compatible for Keurigs and Nespresso® VertuoPlusLine.
Your best Aussie mate is a real greenthumb: Playful, even-keeled, and good for the soul (because these sustainable capsules can be composted at home). This light roast piques curiosity—with a nuanced complexity you can enjoy all day. All capsules are only compatible for Nespresso® Original machines. Not compatible for Keurigs and Nespresso® VertuoPlusLine.
For arvos, after-suppers, and any time you crave a cup—but not the kick. This decaffeinated espresso sets the bar for full-bodied flavor without force—because who doesn’t love to have their cake and eat it, too? All capsules are only compatible for Nespresso® Original machines. Not compatible for Keurigs and Nespresso® VertuoPlusLine.
Our legendary drip coffee is balanced and versatile—a staple for cold-brewers and filter fans. Like all our roasts, Flagstaff is a blend of meticulously, direct-sourced beans grown by farmers who we proudly call mates. BEST FOR: cold brew and filter extraction
Bluestone Lane signature espresso blend. This is what we use in all our shops. Designed to perfectly complement milk with rich notes of cocoa, clove and honeycomb – expect a cup that is well-structured and has a creamy, full-bodied mouthfeel.
A dark roast made for bold strides, long rides, and rising tides. Bold-but-complex, Riptide is big flavor on an even keel—for every ebb, and all the flow. Roasted for early risers and dawn riders. BEST FOR: espresso shots & long blacks
Your best Aussie mate. Never one to turn down an adventure or an all-nighter, but always keen on a beach day, a good book, and a comfortable silence. Bayside is curious but dependable—a nuanced light roast made for all-day, any-way sipping. BEST FOR: lattes & coffee based bevvys
For arvos, after-suppers, and any time you crave a cup—but not the kick. This decaffeinated espresso sets the bar for full-bodied flavor without force—because who doesn’t love to have their cake and eat it, too?
1QT Califia Barista Edition Oat Milk. Vegan, Gluten-Free, Kosher, & Dairy-Free and made with whole rolled, gluten free oats grown in North America. This oat milk steams beautifully, perfectly pairs with coffee, and tastes dang-good by itself with no gums or stabilizers.
1QT Califia Barista Edition Almond Milk. Vegan, Gluten-Free, Kosher, & Dairy-Free with full-bodied goodness, this milk functions as both a "steamer" and creamer for your daily fix of BL coffee or HUSK granola.
*2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary. Additional nutritional information available upon request.
